Journal of Social and Political

Sciences

ISSN 2615-3718 (Online)

ISSN 2621-5675 (Print)

Published: 06 May 2019

A Comparative Study on the Afghan-China Relation Based on Afghan-US relation

Zabehullah Bashardost

Shandong University, China

pdf download

Download Full-Text Pdf

10.31014/aior.1991.02.02.70

Pages: 285-304

Keywords: Afghan-China Relation, Afghan-US Relation, Copenhagen School Theory, Geopolitical Position, National Interest (Mutual Benefit)

Abstract

This paper shows and highlights the broad development friendly ties between Afghanistan and the People's Republic of China (PRC) and wants to investigate the effective factors which affect the relationship with the help of theoretically informed sources and historical narratives. The study shows the relationship that started with the ancient Silk Road that passed through Afghanistan, to recent cooperation represented by Afghanistan's membership in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, AIIB, and OBOR, altogether indicate the continuation of this relationship with the friendly and neighboring country of the People's Republic of China. Moreover, the study tries to explain the differences between Afghan-China relations in comparison with Afghan-American relations. The study adopts Copenhagen school theories based on geopolitics context. Also, this paper tries to respond to this question that, which factors are more important for shaping strength in the relationship of Afghanistan and China based on Afghan- American relation? And is based on the assumption that Afghanistan and China are two neighboring countries with shared values and interests, and these common interests play an effective role in the security, economy, and stability of Afghanistan.

References

  1. Aadili, Zakiya. (2017). Afghanistan's Foreign Policy. Episode 01, Aryana TV. https: //www. YouTube .com/watch=_ru SBFfQyUw&t=22s.

  2. Abedi, Afifa. (2017). Russian Options Against the New American Strategy for Afghanistan. Iranian Studies Institute of Eurasia. Afet, deva. “Afghanistan: Challenges and perspectives until 2020”. http://www.europarl. Europa.eu/Reg Data/etudes STUD/ 2017/578033 /EXPO_STU (2017) 578033_EN.pdf

  3. Afghanistan sputnik. (2017). "if the US become out from Afghanistan, what should happen." https:// af.sputniknews.com/opinion/201708131596831.

  4. Afghanistan. silk road: dialogue, diversity & development. Accessed  https:// en.unesco .org/ silkroad/countries-alongside-silk-road-routes/afghanistan.

  5. Afghanistan's Membership and Challenges in Asia Infrastructure Investment Bank. (2017). Accessed. The Quarterly of Afghanistan ru. http://www. farsi.ru/doc/14404.html.

  6. Afghanistan in the geopolitical dimension of security of Eurasia. (2014). Accessed: http://csef.ru/en/oborona-i-bezopasnost/340/afganistan-v-geopoliticheskom-izmerenii-bezopasnosti-evrazii-5928.

  7. Afghan mines. Accessed in Google. Wikipedia/ https://fa.wikipedia.org/wiki. http:// www. iras.ir/ fa/doc/note/3328.

  8. Ahmadi, Hossein. (2010). Regional Developments of Afghanistan (on the occasion of the International Conference on the Joint Heritage of Iran and Afghanistan). Accessed: http://www.iichstore.ir/product_info.php/products_id/197/pname.

  9. Ahmadi, Ali. (2016). Improving China-Afghanistan Security Relationship. Information Day newspaper.  Accessed: https://www.etilaatroz.com/wp./2016/07/Vol-1102-for-web.pdf.   

  10.  Aliyar, Darab Ali. (2017). One Belt One Road; Extends win-win strategy for China and Afghanistan. Accessed: http://dailyafghanistan.com/opinion _detail. php? post_ id=139980.

  11. Ammar. (2013). The position of Afghanistan in the role of regional initiatives of China. Accessed: issue 201. https://8am.af/x8am/1395/02/20/afghanistan-dream-china-connection-road.

  12. Andishmand, Mohammad Akram. (2007).We and Pakistan". Accessed: Paiman publishing: https:// www.ariaye.com/ketab/andeshmand/andeshmand4.html.

  13. Arabnews. (2018). Pakistan and China push for peace in Afghanistan. Accessed: www.arab news.com/node/1421226.

  14. Azrabsh, Mohammad Taqhi. (2017). The place of Security in the Copenhagen School: A Framework for Analysis”. Quarterly Journal of Political Science. Accessed: Code: 0E7958F. http://www.did.ir/ catalog/index. aspx? Cn =0E7958F.

  15. Babran, Sediqhah and Hatif Poor Rushishidi. (2002). The study of Iran's media diplomacy in Afghanistan after the fall of the Taliban." Middle Studies journal: 131-142. Spring 2011. http://mediastudies.srbiau.ac.ir/article_4349.html.

  16. Baggiani, Gregorio. (2014). Russia-Afghanistan relations: bilateral interests after the War. EPOS Insights, Online page.

  17. Bahin, Sultan Ahmad. (2015). Silk Road and convergence. Accessed: The 8am newspaper/8am.af/x8am/1394/08/09/silk-and-regional-integration.

  18. Beeson, Mark, and Fujian Li. (2015). What consensus? Geopolitics and policy paradigms in China and the United States. Accessed: International Affairs 91. https: //www. chathamhouse.org/sites/default/files/.../INTA911_06_Beeson_Li. pd

  19. Chéné, Hugo. (2014). China in Afghanistan (balancing power projection and minimal intervention)”. Accessed: IPCS. https://www.files.ethz. ch/ isn/194198 /IPCSS special Report_ ChinainAfghanistan_HugoChene.pdf.

  20. China wants to create a contact group for peace process of Afghanistan. (2019). Accessed: TOLO TV. News service,6pm,22 February/www.youtube. com/watch? v=N km TI Qpgm JY.

  21. Challenges and opportunities for China to invest in Afghanistan. (2013). Accessed: National Coalition of Afghanistan (NCA).  www.nca.af/china-Afganistan-f2013011502.html.

  22.  China -Afghanistan relationship. (2014). Accessed: Embassy of the people's republic of China in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. http://af.china-embassy.org/eng.

  23. China- Afghan relatin . Google, Wikipedia, https:// en.wikipedia. org/wiki/ Afghanistan% E2%80%93China_relations.

  24. Epatko, Larisa. (2014). A Historical Timeline of Afghanistan. Accessed: PBS. https:// www. pbs.org/newshour/politics/asia-jan-june11-timeline-afghanistan.

  25. Ezzati, Ezzatollah. (2005). Geostrategy.  Accessed:  http://ensani.ir/fa/article/author/23373.

  26. Faraji Rad, Abdolreza, and others. (2011). The new geopolitics of Afghanistan after 9/11 and its impact on national security in Iran. the Quarterly of Human Geography (2):193-205. Accessed spring 2012. http://www.magiran. com/view.asp? Type=pd f& ID= 976080&l= fa.

  27. Fard, Aziz Ahammad. (2014). Foreign aid to Afghanistan and administration corruption. Worldwide Voice Journal. http://fa.rfi.fr/ 20141204.

  28. Friedman, Norman. (2007). Terrorism, Afghanistan and America’s New Way of War, Annapolis. Naval Institute Press.

  29. Ghiasy, Richard  . (2017). Opinion: why Afghanistan’s stability is so important to China. Accessed: China morning post. https://www.scmp. com/news/china/diplomacy-defence/ article/2095156/opinion-why-afghanistans-stability-so-important-china.

  30. Gorjestani, Tavassoli. (2017). The Design of one belt one road from Dream to Reality. Accessed: Daily Afghanistan Ma. http://www.dailya fghanistan.com/opinion_ detail. php? post_ id= 139991.

  31. Hettne, B. (1999). Globalization and the new Regionalism: The Second Great Transformation. London. McMillian Press. Accessed: www.palgrave .com/us/book /9780312215637.

  32. Huasheng, Z. (2012). China and Afghanistan: China’s Interests, Stances, and Perspectives". Centre for Strategic and International Studies. Washington DC. Accessed: https://csis-prod.s3 .amazonaws.com/s3fs public/legacy files/files/ publication/ 120322_Zhao _China Afghan_ web.pdf.

  33. Huasheng, Zhao. (2016). Afghanistan and China’s new neighborhood diplomacy". The Royal Institute of International Affairs 92 (2016): 891-908. DOI: 10.1111/1468-2346.12654.

  34. Hossain Ershad, Zakir. (2014). Four decades of Afghanistan-US Relations”. Accessed: http:// www.bbc.com/persian/afghanistan/2014/10/141001_k04_afg_us_relation.

  35. How will the Belt and Road Initiative advance China’s interests? China power, unpacking the complexity of Chinas rise. Accessed https://chinapower.csis.org/china-belt-and-road-initiative.

  36. Jamilah, Roohzunda. (2005). A point of view to the History of Political Relations between Iran and Afghanistan (from the Qajar to the Taliban). Accessed: Subhdam Publishing. www.nzdl.org /gsdlmod?

  37.  

  38. Javadi Arjmand, Muhammad Jafar and others. (2015). The Evolution of Foreign Policy of United State toward Afghanistan on the base Geopolitics Theories. Political Sciences Quarterly 32: 33-52. http://psq.kiau.ac.ir/article_520625.html.

  39. Khalil. (2018). The Report of the Seminar on Sino-Afghan Bilateral Ties. CSRS, central for strategic and regional studies. http://csrskabul.com/en/blog/the-report-of-the-seminar-on-sino-afghan-bilateral-ties.

  40. Kyle, David (2017). "A large part of China's global initiative is being implemented in Afghanistan. Accessed: VOA, News, and Social media. https://www.darivoa.com/a/china-keen-to-extend-one-belt-one-way-to-afghanistan/3842385.html.

  41. Lise, Waldek. (2018). Endemic violence in Afghanistan: a socio-culture. Page of Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism, Current Terrorist Trends in the Asia Pacific. https:// doi.org/10.1080/18335330.2018.1473630.

  42. Lynne, O’Donnell. (2016). "China’s MCC turns back on US$3b Mes Aynak Afghanistan mine deal". South China Morning Post. Accessed: http://www .scmp. com/ news/ world/ article/ 1453375/chinas-mcc-turns-back-us3bmes- aynak-Afghanistan-mine-deal.

  43. Mining in Afghanistan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_in_Afghanistan.

  44. Ministry of mines and petroleum of Afghanistan. (2012). Afghanistan, CNPC International Reach Agreement for Amu Darya Oil Tender.  mom. gov. af/ fa/page/momp-contracts/ hydrocarbons-contract.

  45.  Mohmand, Mohammad Rahim. (2017). "Focus on Afghan Trade."  Accessed: http:// moci.gov. af / Content/files/MoCI-Report-Dari-120115.pdf.

  46. Muhammad Khan, Raja. (2015). China's Economic and Strategic Interests in Afghanistan. FWU Journal of Social Sciences. Accessed: National Defence University-Islamabad, http:// sbbwu. edu. pk/journal/images/special%20issue.pdf.

  47. Munadi, Sayed Mahdi. (2014). Afghan-China Relations between2014- 2024: Prospects and Scenarios”. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Accessed: Hazara. Academia.edu/ Sayed Mahdi Munadi.

  48. Munadi, Sayed Mahdi. (2017). Afghanistan Perspective: Economic Initiatives around Afghanistan”. Cooperation or Competitions Between stakeholders. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. https://archivos.juridicas.unam.mx/ www/ bjv/ libros/12/5550/23.

  49. Nasri, Ghadir. (2005). A Methodological Deliberation on the School of Regional Complex of Security.” Strategic Studies Quarterly 29 (2005):585-607.Accessed: http: //quarterly. restudies. org/ article_995.html.

  50. Nia, Mohsen Shariati. (2016). Silk Road Economic Belt: China Value Chain centered”. SID: scientific information database 31:113-85. Accessed august 2016. www. sid.ir/fa/ journal/ View Paper. aspx?id=279704.

  51. Pantucci, R. (2016). "How China is Seen in Afghanistan," Oriental Morning Post. Available at:  http://raffaellopantucci.com/2013/07/05/how-chinais- seen-in-Afghanistan/,

  52. Peshgahi Fard, Zuhra. (2008). The position of Afghanistan in the geostrategy of the new global system. Scientific Journals Management System 8(2008):132-99 . http://jgs.khu.ac.ir/article-۱-۵۵۳-fa.html.

  53. Qaderi, Ali. (2013). Afghanistan's Place in US Foreign Policy Ranking. Afghanistan daily News. http://www.dailyafghanistan.com.

  54. Qadiri, Ali.(2013). “The impact of Afghan-Indian military relations on Afghanistan's relations with the countries of the region.The daily Afghanistan Ma. http:// www. daily afghanistan .com/ opinion_detail.php?post_id=128423.

  55. Round- Table on US-Afghanistan Relations under president Trump. (2017). Institute for Strategic Studies of Afghanistan. Accessed: 82f0508d7adb40ef6e2a57a837a2390b.pdf.

  56. Sakhanyar, Ghulam Muhammad. (2005). fifty years Afghan-China relations (1955-2005). Kabul: Aazim press, the strategic studies center of foreign ministry.

  57. Sadiq, Zia. (2016).the accelerating security relation of Afghanistan and China”. Accessed: 8pm newspaper. 8am.af/x8am/1395/04/07/china-Afghanistan-security.

  58.  Saif, Shadi Khan. (2018). China calls on Taliban to enter Afghan peace process. AA, Anadolu agency.www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/china-calls-on-taliban-to-enter-afghan-peace-process/1339832.

  59. Sajid, Habibollah. Regional integration and foreign policy opportunities of Afghanistan. IbniSina University. https://www.academia.edu/36744553/.

  60. Salimi, Abdul Hakim. (2010). A Study of the Crisis of Afghanistan from a Geopolitical Perspective. Accessed: https://hawzah.net/fa/Article/View/87442/.

  61. Shafiee, Nozar, and Roohallah Salehi Dolat Abad. (2016). Explaining the New Diplomacy of China's Neighborhood towards Afghanistan”. Journal of Central Asia and Caucasus studies 94(2017):71-102.Accessed: http://ca .ipisjournals. ir/article_24262.html.

  62. Shayiri, Ali Shir. (2017). “Silk road”.  Accessed: Khabernama. http:// khabarnama. net/blog/ author/alisher/page/82/.

  63. Shanghai Cooperation Organization. (2018). Google. Wikipedia. Accessed: fa.wikipedia.org/wiki.

  64. Sitiz, Malik. (2010). Political and Strategic Relationships between the United States and Afghanistan”. D.w Afghanistan/www.dw.com/fa-af.

  65. Shams, Ajmal. (2018). China has a role in Afghanistan peace process” The Global Times. http:// www.globaltimes.cn/content/1126002.shtml.

  66. Tahiri, Noor Rahman. (2017). Afghanistan and China Trade Relationship .Munich Personal RePEc Archive, Oruj University. https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen. de/82098/ 1/MPRA_ paper_ 82098.pdf.

  67. Tajeram, M. (2017). Afghanistan Geostrategic Importance. UKessays, trusted by student since 2003. Accessed:www.ukessays.com/essays/politics/brief-history-and-geo-strategic-location-of-afghanistan-politics-essay.

  68. Tamana, Faramarz. (2017).US Foreign Policy in Afghanistan”.

  69. AREU Library Catalogue 202(2008): 202-196.DOI: 327.73056

  70. 733ت 1387, Persian language.

  71. The Eastern Turkistan Terrorist Forces are Guilty (SCIF). (2016). State Council Information Office. http:// www. people. com.cn/ GB/ shizheng/ 3586/20020121/652705.html.

  72. The second round of the National Dialogue Meeting: Afghanistan's Relations with the United States. (2017). Accessed : https:// www.aiss.af/ assets/aiss_ publication/ 104a 2d9b 54dd 97372 f4bddf727979ec8.pdf

  73.  The International Assembly of the Collaboration of One Belt-One Road project. (2017). observatory of International Relations. http:// www. iwpeace. com/sites/ iwpeace .com /files/field/files.pdf.

  74. The Geopolitical Association of Afghanistan: Russian Foreign Policy in Afghanistan. (2016). Strategic Studies institute of Afghanistan. http://geo-af.blogsky. com/ 1395/11/27/post-32/.

  75. Torabi, Qasem and Raziye Saneie.(2015). Explanation of Obstacles to the Realization of Silk from the Perspective of the Convergence Theory”. Political Science Quarterly 35(2016): 7-26. http://psq.kiau.ac.ir/article_528649.html.

  76. Vision and Actions on Jointly Building Silk Road Economic Belt and 21st-Century Maritime Silk Road. (2015). State Council, the National Development and Reform Commission. State Council.

  77. Vosoughi, Saeed, and others. (2005). Explaining Afghanistan as the focal point for several regional sub-systems with an emphasis on the South Asian region and the role of India." Quarterly of Central Asian and Caucasus Studies 87 (2014):303-520. http:// quarterly. Risstudies . org/article_995.html.

  78. William, Paul. (2019). An Introduction to Security Reviews. Trans. Alireza, Tayeb. Tehran, 2011.World Population Review. “Afghanistan Population. Accessed: world population review.com/Afghanistan-population.

  79. Where Will China’s ‘One Belt, One Road’ Initiative Lead. Knowledge &Wharton page (2017). Accessed:  http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/can-chinas-one-belt-one-road-initiative-match-the-hype.

  80. Xinhua. "China calls for new steps, new breakthroughs in Afghan peace process."  Accessed: http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/201812/15/WS5c151060a3107d4c3a001052.html.

  81. Zazai, Ajmal Khan. (2011). Geopolitical analysis of Afghanistan. Michael Yon online magazine. www.michaelyon-online.com/geopolitical-analysis-of-afghanistan. htm.

  82. Zeng, Jinghan, Yuefan Xiao and Shaun, Breslin. (2015). Securing China’s Core Interests: The State of the Debate in China. International Affairs journal 91(2015): 245-266.  https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2346.12233

  83. 1/Afghanistan in the Post–Cold War World. Accessed: http:// www. Washington. edu/ uw press/ samples/GOOAFC1.pdf.

About Us

The Asian Institute of Research is an online and open-access platform to publish recent research and articles of scholars worldwide. Founded in 2018 and based in Indonesia, the Institute serves as a platform for academics, educators, scholars, and students from Asia and around the world, to connect with one another. The Institute disseminates research that is proven or predicted to be of significant influence for the general public.

Stay Connected

  • Instagram - Black Circle
  • Facebook - Black Circle
  • LinkedIn - Black Circle

Contact Us

Please send all inquiries to the email:

editorial@asianinstituteofresearch.org

Business Address:

5th Floor, Kavling 507, Fajar Graha Pena Tower, Jl. Urip Sumohardjo No.20, Makassar, Indonesia 90234

Copyright © 2018 The Asian Institute of Research. All rights reserved